Your Privacy Matters: We use our own and third-party cookies to improve your experience on our website. By continuing to use the website we understand that you accept their use. Cookie Policy
1528
Comparing XamRibbon with Microsofts Ribbon CTP
posted

Has anyone made a detailed comparision of the xamRibbon and Microsofts WPF Ribbon CTP?

How does XamRibbon fair in MVVM scenarios and Blend? Both are an issue with Microsofts CTP1 which they have apparently thrown out and will be replacing shortly.

--Douglas

Parents
No Data
Reply
  • 54937
    Verified Answer
    Offline posted

    There is no specific document comparing the products. It probably wouldn't be worthwhile at this point since the currently available version isn't an accurate depiction of what they will be releasing. 

    With regards to Blend, the control can be used/designed within Blend. I'm not sure if there is a specific concern you had. It also doesn't have the same issue with commands that the original MS Ribbon had whether you were required to use their base command class to provide images, etc. With regards to M-V-VM, it would probably be best to have a layer in between the control and the vm. For example the tabs collection is not currently bindable. It may be possible to add this type of support in the future but it may be better suited to be managed in a separate layer (e.g. a prism region adapter). The xamRibbon supports customizations (e.g. adding ribbon groups and tools to the qat) that make it difficult to allow creating via items control type container generation around a data item.

Children